Lawsuit Accuses Big Bank of Making Big 'Mistakes': Chase overcharges 4000 military families

| 3 Comments | No TrackBacks
Some things never change.  When I sued my mortgage company, many years ago, all I wanted to do was get them to correct their repeated accounting errors.  I wanted to get them to handle my mortgage properly. I wanted my bank--and every other bank--to stop their reckless disregard for the human cost of their repeated accounting "mistakes". I thought all these years later we would see fewer and fewer instances of these mega-sized bank errors but as years have passed, it's become abundantly clear how wrong I was!   

We can hardly keep up with the daily reports about abusive or fraudulent mortgage servicing practices and loan modification runarounds. Homeowners continue to vent their frustrations and share stories of  tremendous hardships created or compounded by, the actions -or in-actions -of their bank.  Mortgage servicing companies have been allowed to continue to turn a deaf ear on the desperate pleas for help from once loyal customers -at least until the bank's hit with a lawsuit that then demands their attention (video below)   

This week we've learned that thousands of military families have been overcharged for their mortgages by JP Morgan Chase bank.  Not only were these families made to pay too much, the inflated bills have ruined their credit and contributed to as many as 14 wrongful foreclosures. At least fourteen families had their homes ripped out from under their feet without cause. I would bet those families did proverbial cartwheels trying to get the attention of someone at Chase -before being locked out of their homes. 

Chase could have gotten away with their violations if not for one tenacious victim.  Marine Captain Jonathan Rowles brought it to light when he hired an attorney to sue Chase Bank for violating a law designed to protect active duty military from financial harm when they themselves are in harm's way. This then got Chase's attention and caused the institution to look at the way it was handling its obligations, particularly to military families.  It appears some 4000 military families have been overcharged on their loans. It's impossible to believe that Chase wasn't aware of this law;

 "Under a law known as the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (SCRA), active-duty troops generally get their mortgage interest rates lowered to 6 percent and are protected from foreclosure. Chase now appears to have repeatedly violated that law, which is designed to protect troops and their families from financial stress while they're in harm's way."

To remedy what the bank says are "honest mistakes", they are voluntarily paying out about $2 million in refunds.  In addition, they claim that many of the wrongfully foreclosed homes have been restored to their owners. (Read: Chase's statement here)

 The military families get some money back, homes are restored, and Chase gets off easily in the cash department (I know 2 million sounds like a lot but it's a very small drop in the bucket for Chase, and it averages out to about $500 per family).  Everybody's happy, right?  Wrong. Banks are STILL just as prone to error as they ever were, and it is STILL the customer's responsibility to check--and if need be, sue--to get a bank to behave by the rules.  That's just not right.

The truth is, a lawsuit is costly and draining and, believe me, a last-resort tactic. The Rowels, like most of us, simply want our banks to fulfill their fiduciary duty to handle our mortgage properly.  When a bank cannot or will not comply with that simple directive, that defiance should be perceived as acts of reckless and conscious disregard -NOT "honest mistakes".  

Why does it take a lawsuit to get people to do the right thing? This story is yet another in a long line of examples that illustrate why we should all be grateful that we still have access to the courts.  If the banking lobbyists had their way -we wouldn't be able to deter or correct financial wrongs and predatory practices a/k/a "honest mistakes". Right now, the Supreme Court is deciding on AT&T Mobility v Concepcion, a case that could limit the ways in which consumers can right the wrongs perpetrated on them by banks and other large corporations.

If AT&T wins this one, corporations will have the right to include in their contracts wording that prevents consumers from suing them in a class action lawsuit.  We need to fight to maintain the ability to deter and correct corporate wrongs, or "mistakes" like those that cost these military families untold grief will never be found out. (READ: Update on Supreme Court Ruling here.)

See also: Torrey Shannon's article: JP Morgan-Chase "Accidentally" Foreclosed on Military Mortgages: Violated Decades of Existing Law 

Visit for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Enhanced by Zemanta

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL:


I have a loan with EMC-Chase and have several wrongs in my paperwork. I have been able to delay foreclosure 4 times now. Who would you recommend I use to sue them? I had a forensic report done and there are so many things that are fraudulent. Can you help me with finding an attorney? This home has been in my family for 38 yrs and we are all afraid my brother, who has been there for the 38 yrs will commit suicide if he loses it. I was able to buy it 6 yrs ago to save it then. My original note was for $220K and I have paid over $60K and the bank says I owe over $255K. I would so love your advice on where to turn.
Thanx and have a blessed day!
Mark Jennings

I am looking to sue chase bank but are,not able to find a lawyer. i purchased a condo,,had the people at the bank set it all up for me to make my payments online they put in the info, address ect. I made my payments on time but when they were made they would be sent to the wrong address which (they put in ) causing me to be late for many months , even though they were all electronic payments i was late. not always checking my monthly statements, i use online which doesn't show you are late, i finally went to my local branch where they know me very well. admitted it was their mistake Valerie who know me corrected the address, but (too bad ) they won;t do anything to correct my late charges or clean my credit record. now i can,t refinance with a lower interest rate. or get a loan for my stepdaughter for college. any ideas or names of lawyers? thanks.

Leave a comment

A memoir exposing the steep price consumers pay when facing mortgage servicing errors, inaccurate credit reporting, illegal debt collection practices, identity theft and weak consumer protection laws. THE BOOK » DENISE'S STORY »